Mid-Season Rookie Report: Tight Ends

As the 2025 NFL season reaches its midpoint, this class of rookie tight ends has certainly captured attention. Typically, tight ends require time to acclimate to the speed and physicality inherent in professional football, yet this particular group has defied the norm. These five players have already established themselves as pivotal components of their teams’ offensive schemes, exhibiting both volume and impressive efficiency.

1) Tyler Warren — Indianapolis Colts

Warren has entered the league and performed like a seasoned professional right from the beginning. He executes precise routes, identifies open space in coverage, and seldom drops the ball. The Indianapolis Colts rely on him during critical situations, a trust that he has reciprocated with substantial contributions. Warren possesses a 19% target share, the highest among rookie tight ends, and boasts an average of 1.95 yards per route run, illustrating his effectiveness when on the field. His combination of resilience and situational awareness has rendered him a trustworthy safety net for his quarterback.

2) Colston Loveland — Chicago Bears

Loveland is swiftly becoming a beloved player among fans in Chicago. He demonstrates impressive athleticism, self-assuredness, and is already revealing traits of a well-rounded tight end. The Bears are increasing his involvement week by week, particularly on play-action passes and during red zone opportunities. With an 11% target share and an outstanding 2.1 fantasy points per target, Loveland is establishing his capability to move the chains and complete scoring drives. His burgeoning rapport with the Bears’ youthful offense offers Chicago promising prospects for the future.

3) Oronde Gadsden — Los Angeles Chargers

Few rookies have made as thrilling plays as Gadsden. Standing at 6’5”, he induces mismatches across the field. He is too swift for linebackers and too powerful for safeties. Gadsden is averaging a 14% target share and an exceptional 2.32 yards per route run, making it one of the premier figures in the entire rookie class. He has rapidly gained the trust of quarterback Justin Herbert, providing the Chargers with an exciting new asset in an already dynamic offense.

4) Harold Fannin — Cleveland Browns

Fannin has quietly emerged as a reliable target within Cleveland’s offense, working alongside veteran David Njoku. He excels in gaining yards after the catch and demonstrates dependability in short-yardage situations, which aids in sustaining drives. With an average of 6.4 targets per game and 1.66 yards per route run, he is delivering commendable performance despite the fluctuations in quarterback play. As the Browns' offense continues to evolve, Fannin seems well-positioned to develop in tandem.

5) Mason Taylor — New York Jets

While Taylor may lack the flamboyance of some of his peers, he is asserting his value through unwavering consistency and diligent effort. He ranks among the top two players on the Jets in total targets, establishing himself as one of the team’s most reliable short-range options. Although his stats reflect 0.95 yards per route run and 5.8 yards per target, indicating potential for growth, Taylor’s reliability and tenacity are commendable. He embodies the type of player who cultivates his quarterback’s confidence, a relationship that often translates into greater opportunities.

Bottom Line

This cohort of rookie tight ends is ahead of expectations. Tyler Warren is already projecting as a long-term starter. Colston Loveland is developing valuable chemistry in Chicago. Oronde Gadsden possesses the tools to evolve into a star, while Harold Fannin and Mason Taylor are carving out their niches. Collectively, they contribute to making the 2025 rookie tight end class one of the most exhilarating in recent memory.

Insights from the Deep Dive Fantasy Football Podcast